Item-Specific and Relational Encoding, but not Warnings, are Effective at Reducing the Illusion of Competence
Date of Award
Honors College Thesis
Mark Huff, Ph.D.
Metamemory, or the ability to understand the capacities of one’s own memory, is an important part of the learning process. One method for assessing metamemory is through the Judgment of Learning (JOL) task in which participants are asked to judge the likelihood of correctly remembering a target word in a cue-target word pair when only presented with a cue word at test. The associative direction of the cue-target pair has been shown to affect the accuracy of JOLs. Unlike forward pairs (e.g., credit-card), in which JOLs accurately predict recall, an illusion of competence has been reported for backward associates (e.g., card-credit), symmetrical associates (e.g., salt-pepper), and unrelated pairs (e.g., artery-bronze) in which JOLs overestimate later recall. The present study evaluates whether the illusion of competence pattern can be reduced or eliminated when participants use an item-specific or relational encoding strategy relative to reading (Experiment 1), and whether these encoding tasks are aided by warning participants about the illusion prior to study (Experiment 2). Across experiments, item-specific and relational encoding were found to reduce the illusion of competence for backward and unrelated pairs; however, warnings did not improve JOL estimations. Thus, the method of encoding, but not warnings, can facilitate JOL accuracy.
Copyright for this thesis is owned by the author. It may be freely accessed by all users. However, any reuse or reproduction not covered by the exceptions of the Fair Use or Educational Use clauses of U.S. Copyright Law or without permission of the copyright holder may be a violation of federal law. Contact the administrator if you have additional questions.
Cates, Emily, "Item-Specific and Relational Encoding, but not Warnings, are Effective at Reducing the Illusion of Competence" (2021). Honors Theses. 820.