Date of Award
Summer 6-2022
Degree Type
Dissertation
Degree Name
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)
School
Communication
Committee Chair
Steven Venette
Committee Chair School
Communication
Committee Member 2
Kathryn Anthony
Committee Member 2 School
Communication
Committee Member 3
John Meyer
Committee Member 3 School
Communication
Committee Member 4
Paul Alberti-Strati
Committee Member 4 School
Communication
Committee Member 5
Laura Alberti
Committee Member 5 School
Communication
Abstract
This dissertation used Power of Speech Style (POS) theory’s powerless linguistic cues (hedges, hesitations, intensifiers, and tag questions), Information Manipulation Theory and McCroskey’s Speaker Credibility Scale to determine if perceived honesty mediates the relations between a speaker’s use of powerless linguistic cues and evaluations of that speaker’s credibility. Two studies were conducted. The first study tested these variables' relationships with an experimental design involving reading a courtroom witness transcript. An EFA was conducted to determine appropriate factors for perceived information manipulation. Then mediation analysis using PROCESS included four parallel mediators from the previously tested EFA. The second study provided replication and extension of study one by including three new message transcript scenarios between physician-patient, politician-constituent, and professor-student. Additional covariables such as gender, lie acceptance, political affiliation, perceived threat severity of pain medication, and student responsibility were included to account for any undue influence on the dependent variables. The results produced a new measurement with a CFA for the Information Manipulation Scale (IMS), a reordering of items for the factor structure of speaker credibility, and advice for improving speaker credibility by prioritizing the removal of hesitations from one’s speech. Additionally, intensifiers were identified as not being powerless linguistic cues and should not be included in future studies of POS. Future research was proposed for how to overcome limitations of these studies, and various ways in which the new IMS and speaker credibility measurements can be tested and further validated.
ORCID ID
0000-0002-6448-9656
Recommended Citation
Bryant, Kevin, "POWER-OF-SPEECH STYLES’ HEDGES, HESITATIONS, INTENSIFIERS, AND TAG QUESTIONS EFFECTS ON PERCEIVED INFORMATION MANIPULATION, HONESTY, AND SPEAKERS’ CHARACTER, COMPETENCE, AND SOCIABILITY: A MULTI-PARALLEL AND SERIAL MEDIATION EXPLORATION" (2022). Dissertations. 2031.
https://aquila.usm.edu/dissertations/2031